FIA knew seven years ago that V6 sound would be “unappealing”

The sound of the 2014 F1 power units has been a subject of discussion since the Australian GP, and a negative reaction from many fans has hardly comes as a surprise.

The sound does not come across well on TV, or to those watching the cars blast down a straight. However it is much better appreciated live by those spectating in corners, and hearing the drivers go down and up the gears.

The always controversial Melbourne F1 boss Ron Walker was quick to join the debate, complaining that he didn’t get the show that he’d signed up for.

Intriguingly seven years ago the FIA was made aware that engine noise could be an issue once the sport switched to turbo power.

In June 2007 the FIA produced a document called “Formula One 2011: Power-Train Regulation Framework,” subtitled “A Briefing Note for the Formula One Manufacturers’ Advisory Committee Meeting, June 2007.”

Commissioned by Max Mosley and prepared by FIA advisors Tony Purnell and Peter Wright, it provided the guidelines that ultimately led to the new regulations, albeit three years later than was originally anticipated.

Although there would be many other documents, much (but not all) of the above report eventually translated into the 2014 rules pushed through by Mosley’s successor Jean Todt.

Purnell and Wright were well aware that the fans had to be taken into account, writing: “The main constraint will be to avoid damage to the emotional attraction of Formula One for its fan base. In particular the technical awe of Formula One and its sheer speed must be retained.”

Regarding the sound made by what was then intended a 2.2-litre V6, they wrote: “The noise of high rpm is to be replaced, by what we don’t know, but it will be quieter. The view is that the risk of this new noise being unappealing is a risk worth taking. Quieter cars are 100% in line with environment demands. The unique and sophisticated power-trains are certain to make a dramatic, if very different noise of their own.”

It will be fascinating to see if the FIA formally investigates the possibility of ramping up the sound for 2015, possibly by mandating a new exhaust design.

16 Comments

Filed under F1 News, Grand Prix News

April 14 chosen for Red Bull appeal hearing

As expected Red Bull’s appeal against the exclusion of Daniel Ricciardo from the results of the Australian GP will be heard between the Bahrain and Chinese events.

The FIA confirmed today that the International Court of Appeal hearing will take place at 0930 in Paris on Monday April 14. Given the usual time constraints it was never going to happen any earlier than the gap between the two races.

A short statement said: “On 16 March 2014 the panel of the stewards decided to exclude car No. 3 (driver Daniel Ricciardo) from the results of the race as it was found being out of compliance with the Technical Regulations (the Technical Delegate reported to the Stewards that car No. 3 exceeded the required fuel mass flow of 100kg/h).

“On 20 March 2014, the Österreichischer Automobil-Motorrad und Touring Club – Oberste Nationale Sportkommission für den Motorsport (ÖAMTC-OSK) on behalf of its licence-holder, Infiniti Red Bull Racing, decided to appeal this decision before the International Court of Appeal.”

1 Comment

Filed under F1 News, Grand Prix News

James Allison: “We have our work cut out…”

Ferrari technical director James Allison has described the team’s form in Australia as “not acceptable,” and says that straightline speed and braking stability – a big problem for Kimi Raikkonen in particular – are among the key areas for improvement.

Fernando Alonso finished 35 seconds behind winner Nico Rosberg, who is assumed by most observers to have had a lot in hand.

“Our competitiveness was not acceptable in Melbourne,” Allison told the Ferrari website. “But we intend to fight our way back up the grid with the improvements that we will bring to the car.

“While we can take some satisfaction from the reliability shown by the F14T, it is clear that we have our work cut out to improve our car in order to compete on equal terms with the Mercedes team. There is plenty about the F14T that is working very well. The starts and the pace in the corners – especially the high speed ones – are particular strong points, but we need to work further on the stability under braking, and the speed on the straights.”

Allison remains confident that there is time to recover.

“All the recent seasons in F1 have been characterised by a fierce development battle from March until November. With all the new regulations this year, the opportunities to improve the car are legion, and we can expect the race to improve the cars to be even more intense than normal.”

5 Comments

Filed under F1 News, Grand Prix News

Magnussen brilliant on debut, says Boullier

McLaren racing director Eric Boullier says that the team did everything right on its way to earning what became second and third places in Australia.

He was also full of praise for rookie Kevin Magnussen.

“I think all the credit is going to the people as well in Woking,” he said when asked by this writer. “Because after a difficult last year they learned from their mistakes, and they kept their head cool, and obviously this weekend it ran smoothly. Everybody learned and gathered the data we needed and worked very hard to go to the end of the race with the best performance. We did a good strategy. The calls from the pit wall were good, and obviously the drivers did an awesome job.”

Regarding Magnussen’s performance, he said: “It was brilliant to be honest, from a young kid like him. He handled the pressure brilliantly.”

Boullier admits however that Mercedes is a long way clear of the rest.

“Yes, there is a huge gap, but we knew this already from Bahrain. We just have to work to get close to them now.”

1 Comment

Filed under F1 News, Grand Prix News

Ron Dennis: “We know when we can realistically expect to win…”

On Sunday evening Ron Dennis made no secret of his satisfaction with not just at the performance of Kevin Magnussen, but also of the whole McLaren team, which earned second and third places after Daniel Ricciardo’s exclusion.

The pit wall made some particularly good calls with Jenson Button, which helped the Brit to leap frog up the order.

“The team was very structured, very focussed, and made the right decisions in the right way,” he said when asked by this writer. “It’s good. We’re not here to come third, we’re here to win. We certainly won’t be satisfied until we win. The structure is maturing well, and we will win.”

Prior to Australia Dennis said his role wouldn’t involve being on the pit wall, and while he changed his mind, he said he wasn’t taking over from Eric Boullier.

“I wasn’t on the pit wall telling him what to do, I was really just trying to understand the strategy as it was being remodelled through the race. I’m a racer, so the thought of not understanding and contributing doesn’t come across my mind. It’s just when you observe things it’s good to say, ‘Why not this, why not that?’

“It’s a luxury not to have a role in the team, if you stand back, you can watch what’s going on. The thing is everybody is receptive to change, everybody knows we have to change, and when you change things you get better. The outcome of today was a really good team effort. They called the pit stops at the right time, they were agile with the safety car, stops were all well executed tyre utilisation, fuel, everything was well executed.

“I’m pleased about the discipline of the team. Everyone knows what we have to do, and we’ve just got to get on and do it.”

Regarding the team’s potential he said: “We don’t have the pace yet, but this earlier races are when you can accumulate points. We have very clear mile stones of input performance, we know when we can realistically expect to win races, don’t ask the question, I’m not going to tell you. You don’t arrive back where you want to be just overnight, it takes time.

“I’ll come to more than 10 [races], and less than 16, I don’t know where that will fit. Most of the reason I come to the races is either investors or shareholders, or meetings that need to be attended.”

1 Comment

Filed under F1 News, Grand Prix News

Williams should have been on podium, says Wolff

Toto Wolff is not underestimating the opposition, and the Mercedes boss says both Williams and Red Bull could have been more competitive in Australia.

Wolff suggests that Red Bull would have been more of a threat had Sebastian Vettel not had a troubled weekend.

“If you see where they [RBR] were two weeks ago, we need to be very careful,” said Wolff. “We haven’t seen Sebastian running with a reliable car and a fast car, and you would expect him, with his experience, to go even faster. So we have to keep on pushing.”

While his Williams team mate Felipe Massa was out at the first corner Valterri Bottas was one of the few drivers who could overtake in Australia, and he finished fifth despite losing time when he clipped the wall early on

“I guess if you look at Valtteri’s pace before he hit the wall, and then I think his steering wheel was not completely straight, and then his pace afterwards, I would say if they have a normal race and they qualify better than here, probably they would have ended up on the podium. I’m quite sure they would have ended up on the podium.”

Leave a comment

Filed under F1 News, Grand Prix News

Mercedes not resting on laurels, Wolff insists

Toto Wolff admits that he would regard it as a failure if Mercedes does not win the 2014 World Championship – although he insists that the team’s advantage is not as big as outsiders might think.

“I don’t see it as a big advantage, to be honest,” he said. “You can see if you have a DNF, you lose points. McLaren is leading the constructors’. So we cannot pause in the whole thing. Yes, we have a little bit of a margin at the moment, and losing that margin now is something that I would consider as a failure.”

Wolff says that the team has to keep on pushing, and not rest on its laurels.

“The good thing is that we are very integrated, it’s not that you work on reliability and not on the other parts. The whole thing is so much integrated, and the guys work with each other so well that, yes, we have to continue to work on reliability, but equally drive performance. You need to add downforce to the car, you need to make all the systems work with each other, you need to improve on cooling, you need to improve the whole package of the car.

“You have to look on yourself, and improve everything, and improve the organisation, and improve the car. Whether you are ahead or behind, it doesn’t change the approach.”

He acknowledged that the next race is a big challenge: “I guess that all the teams are fighting with cooling at the moment. We tend to find out every test or race weekend that we are going into that it’s more challenging than expected, so I guess Malaysia will be quite a big challenge to manage heat.”

1 Comment

Filed under F1 News, Grand Prix News

Stefano Domenicali: “It’s like the cat has to bite the tail…”

Stefano Domencali says that Ferrari has a lot of work to do before the next race in Malaysia – and is adamant that there won’t be any allocation of blame between the engine and chassis departments for the team’s form in Australia.

“We have a lot of things to do,” he said. “And what we need to do is to go home and make sure that the things that have to be are solved in the group are clear, with a clear responsibility. And then full stop, and no other discussion.

“We had some issue which was related to the fact that we couldn’t really use full power every lap, so it was connected to some bigger issue that we have to manage. I really hope that we will ready to be at a certain level, or at least to solve the issue that we had, already at the next race in Malaysia.

Regarding fuel consumption he said: “For sure that area is an area where we know we need to improve. You know it seems not logical, but the more power that you have, the less you stay on full throttle. We have also benefit on the fuel consumption side. So it’s like the cat has to bite the tail. For sure that’s an area where we have to improve a lot, but I don’t want to focus only on that, because also the car has to be improved.

“It’s a matter of everyone doing his job, and making sure they are focussed on what they have to do at home, without trying to say this is your fault, my fault. As a team we need to react together, and that’s what I’ve asked to all my engineers and all my people.”

Domenicali says the team will also focus on helping Kimi Raikkonen, who has had more problems with the F14 T than his team mate.

“I think we need to help Kimi in trying to find the right balance with the car, helping him because he deserves that. I think there was an improvement during the days. We are still not where we want, because this is something that as a team we want to make sure that everything will be done in order to help his driving style. I’m also sure that for Malaysia will be much better.”

7 Comments

Filed under F1 News, Grand Prix News

Kimi Raikkonen: “I’m sure we can only get better from here…”

Kimi Raikkonen left Australia with seventh place to his name after Daniel Ricciardo’s exclusion gifted him a place, but it certainly wasn’t an easy weekend for the Finn on his comeback to Ferrari.

A crash in qualifying was just one of his problems as he struggled to come to terms with the F14 T, and he was seen locking up in the race.

“The brakes are fine, always we had a little issue with it at the beginning of the race,” he said. “But then we grained the front tyre, and obviously when you do that you don’t have the grip on the front, then you lock very easily, and it understeers, that’s the main issue. It’s not the brakes, it’s a combination of things. Sometimes it gets a bit tricky.

“Unfortunately right now it’s not the easiest thing, but I’m sure we will find a solution for it at some point. It’s not the first time I’ve been in a situation that’s not easy, and we’ll work until we fix the things. If it takes a week, a month, I don’t care. It’s not the first time, that’s how it goes some times.”

Asked about the prospects for improving the situation he added: “We know more or less what we want to do. Obviously it’s not happening overnight, it takes time to produce certain parts or a certain way putting the things. We cannot promise that we’re going to fix the issue once we get something that we want.

“We can hope that it will work, but like I said I’ve been in situations before, and sometimes it takes a while. Unfortunately not the most easy position right now, but looking how difficult everything was, we still got something out. Obviously not what we want to achieve, but it could have been even worse. I’m sure we can only get better from here.

“I think if we can run the weekend without any issues, and the race without problems, I’m sure we can be much stronger. This is how it was here, and hopefully we can sort out most of the things for the next race.

“It wasn’t a very enjoyable race and not as strong we wanted, but the weekend overall I think we learned a lot, and hopefully we can cut down the problems and mistakes and get better.”

2 Comments

Filed under F1 News, Grand Prix News

Video: Nico Rosberg on his Australian win

Here’s what a very happy Nico Rosberg has to say about his Australian GP victory.

Leave a comment

Filed under Grand Prix history, Grand Prix News